preprint وصول مفتوح

Bayyinah al-Munāsabāt: A Multi-Corpus, Multi-Pipeline Falsification Study of Canonical-versus-Chronological Long-Range Autocorrelation in the Uthmanic Quran

  • Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
  • European Organization for Nuclear Research
Research footprint

At a glance

الاستشهادات
0
المراجع
0
Comments
0
Paper overview

Abstract

This paper reports a multi-round, multi-corpus falsification investigation testing whether the structural autocorrelation properties of the canonical Uthmanic Quran (114 surahs) are properties of the underlying revelation chronology, of the canonical's approximate length-sorted compilation structure, or of intra-quartile structural ordering decisions distinct from both. The canonical Quran is tested against the Cairo 1924 standard chronology, the verbatim Nöldeke-Schwally 1860 chronology, within-length-quartile shuffles, and four negative-control corpora drawn from the same broad linguistic and religious tradition: three canonical Sunni hadith collections (Sahih al-Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Muwatta Malik), the Hebrew Bible at the book level under both Protestant 39-book and Tanakh 24-book orderings, and twenty-eight diwans of pre-Islamic Arabic poetry including all seven Muʿallaqāt poets. The pipeline (TF-IDF normalized cosine similarity, Fibonacci-additive growth metric, multi-lag autocorrelation) is applied uniformly across three independent tokenization regimes (Tashaphyne morphological roots, Qalsadi citation-form lemmas, character 3-grams without morphological processing). The headline finding: approximately 70 to 82 percent of the canonical Quran's apparent autocorrelation gap over random shuffles is attributable to its approximate length-sort, not to deeper intra-quartile ordering; the remaining residual (+0.15 to +0.25 at lag 20 depending on tokenization) survives Bonferroni-corrected family-wise significance at all four tested lags under the orthogonal character 3-gram pipeline and at lags 5 and 20 under the Qalsadi pipeline. The Hebrew Bible in Tanakh ordering shows distinct short-range genre clustering that decays to noise by lag 10, qualitatively different from the Quran's sustained pattern out to lag 30. A numerical discrepancy with Cross-Text Computational Linguistics §3.3 (which reports +0.53 at lag 20 where the present paper reports +0.80) is documented and preserved as unresolved per the program's reconciliation discipline. Status: candidate-finding under Cross-Text §6 Caveat 1; independent replication by a research group not the present author, with pre-registered lag thresholds and pipeline choices, is invited. All corpora are publicly available; all scripts run reproducibly in approximately five minutes on a typical laptop.

Record transparency

Publication details

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20069653
OpenAlex
W7160496469
Document type
preprint
Language
EN
Source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Last metadata update
المجتمع

Comments

تسجيل الدخول للانضمام إلى النقاش.

  1. لا توجد تعليقات بعد. ابدأ النقاش.