YaleNLP @ PerAnsSumm 2025: Multi-Perspective Integration via Mixture-of-Agents for Enhanced Healthcare QA Summarization

Automated summarization of healthcare community question-answering forums is challenging due to diverse perspectives presented across multiple user responses to each question.The PerAnsSumm Shared Task was therefore proposed to tackle this challenge by identifying perspectives from different answers and then generating a comprehensive answer to the question.In this study, we address the PerAnsSumm Shared Task using two complementary paradigms: (i) a trainingbased approach through QLoRA fine-tuning of LLaMA-3.3-70B-Instruct, and (ii) agentic approaches including zero-and few-shot prompting with frontier LLMs (LLaMA-3.3-70B-Instructand GPT-4o) and a Mixture-of-Agents (MoA) framework that leverages a diverse set of LLMs by combining outputs from multi-layer feedback aggregation.For perspective span identification/classification, GPT-4o zero-shot achieves an overall score of 0.57, substantially outperforming the 0.40 score of the LLaMA baseline.With a 2-layer MoA configuration, we were able to improve LLaMA performance up by 28% to 0.51.For perspectivebased summarization, GPT-4o zero-shot attains an overall score of 0.42 compared to 0.28 for the best LLaMA zero-shot, and our 2-layer MoA approach boosts LLaMA performance by 32% to 0.37.Furthermore, in few-shot setting, our results show that the sentence-transformer embedding-based exemplar selection provides more gain than manually selected exemplars on LLaMA models, although the few-shot prompting is not always helpful for GPT-4o.The YaleNLP team's approach ranked the overall second place in the shared task.